|
|
"You," said Dr. Yavitch, "are a middle-road liberal, and you haven't the slightest idea what you want. I, being a revolutionist, know exactly what I want - and what I want right now is a drink" ~~ Sinclair Lewis ~~
Richard, of Commie Curmudgeon, (aka: No More Big Wheels) posted an excellent reply to my list of the Top 10 punk/hardcore albums of all time. Hmm. We're the same age, just about (I was born October 1961), but my punk roots are much more first-wave. Never could see much of the later, hardcore work as comparing to original punk (especially the mid-late '70s stuff that came from either the UK or NYC, where I first heard it in my mid teens).
Oh, well, I could quibble a lot, but I thought I'd make a few minor points (keeping in mind that your "punk" list is a little different from one I would write, because you are focusing on "pure" punk and hardcore, but nonetheless)...
1. I think any list such as this would have to include Wire's Pink Flag.
2. The Avengers should be on any such list, and maybe X (though maybe not hardcore enough for you?) I might add X Ray Spex, though some find them a bit silly.
3. I thought Road to Ruin was already a slight decline for The Ramones. The first three albums were the best. Their very first album was the most incredible, groundbreaking work.
4. Bands from countries other than U.S. or U.K.: The first Saints album was incredibly hardcore, released in late '76 or '77 from Australia!
5. Kleenex/Lilliput (that Swiss band) -- maybe a bit arty for pure punks, but they had a really hard-driving punk sound early on, and they were all women, which I thought was pretty cool.
6. Buzzcocks, especially first EP, which was hardcore punk, unlike later, more poppy material. This was also a historic release because it was the first indie punk recording from the UK (1976).
6. Early Husker Du? Zen Arcade maybe was getting a little arty for hardcores, but it was still mind-numbingly noisy stuff and when I saw them in 1984, I thought it was the hardest-core band I'd ever seen (and I had seen Black Flag in 1981-82!)
I'll stop here. I don't write about music in my blog anymore, so I thought I'd hog some space in yours. (Hope you don't mind.) Obviously, I dont mind. And, if you, Richard, would care to create your own article, I'll gladly post it here. My list is correct, from my perspective. I listed them as the made an impact upon me, and with a general nod to the people around me, my friends, and the scene I hung out in. I will take a stab at answering Richards brief thoughts tomorrow. Hopefully Richard will chime in with more. Hope fully The Common Man, and Rob of DepthMarker will chime in with their own thoughts.
[ ]
|
|
|